Below is a summary of the known
and implied health risks associated with pesticides and by inference
pesticide residues.
Though there is a likelihood of
contact with some level of pesticide residue in day to day life,
this must be considered in the context of the very low levels of
residue and the other similar contaminants that we come into contact
with in our modern world.
Pesticides are Poisons
As poisons, pesticides are inherently dangerous.
However, farmers manage and reduce the risk by both using low
levels and applying some time before the crop is harvested
so that the pesticide degrades into harmless compounds or is
washed off by the rain or other means.
Thus they can be targeted and used at application
levels that kill insects rather than harm humans who subsequently
use the products.
Ultimately, the main health fear associated
with pesticides is not that someone will eat a sprayed apple
and fall ill, but that residues or the products of
their degradation will build up over the years with a risk
of harmful effects developing in the longer term.
These effects are long-term or difficult
to prove they are happening at all; locations and causes are
uncertain and many people prefer not to risk exposure to pesticides
at all and opt for “organic” foods. They prefer
a known risk of natural 'bugs' (see
bbc article) to an unknown risk of a build up in pesticide
residues over many years.
What are "hormone
disruptors"?
A number of pesticides which
are commonly found in our food have been identified by the
European Union as likely to cause disturbance to natural hormones
in our bodies.
These "hormone disruptors" are
said to risk affecting brain development, behaviour, and the
development of reproductive organs.
They have also been associated
with such as falling sperm counts and girls entering puberty
earlier.
The greatest risk from hormone
disruptors is that they can cause problems at very low doses.
Some block the bodies natural hormones from working, while
others mimic the action of natural hormones.
Are
children at greater risk?
Some scientists believe exposure
to pesticides in the womb may be to blame for the growth
of behavioural disorders among children in industrial countries.
They also suspect that subtle
harm done to the brain early in life may not become evident
until much later.
Some pesticides have been
found to weaken the immune system, and concern has even been
raised that exposure to pesticides in the womb could make
individuals more vulnerable to their toxic effects as adults.
And is there
any Protection?
The government sets an "approved
usage" level for each pesticide, which is intended to
define a maximum residue level (MRL), This is effectively a
safety limit on how much of any particular pesticide can make
its way into the food chain.
The September 1999 report from
the "Working
Party on Pesticide Residues" found pesticides in many supermarket
foods, however it was only a small proportion that breached
the limits.
But, the approved usage level
is set down for adults, possibly putting children at risk.
Barbara Dinham, programme director
of the Pesticides Trust said: "Children tend to eat a
lot of fresh fruit and vegetables and there is the worry that
they could be more at risk, especially as there are more pesticides
in food now, so they are growing up accumulating these chemicals."
What
are the prime suspects?
Research has identified several
pesticides that pose a risk to health over a prolonged period
and even with small-scale exposure.
Chlordecone: Leads
to abnormal sperm and affects their ability to move.
Vinclozalin: Another
hormone disruptor used on oilseed rape, apples, peas and
beans, has been shown to cause serious developmental problems
to baby male rats.
Carbendazim: The most
commonly used fungicide in the UK. It has been shown to disrupt
sperm production in the testicles of adult rats, and to damage
the development of mammals in the womb.
Lindane: Linked to
breast and other cancers, and fertility problems.
DDT: Linked to cancer
and male infertility after it was shown to block the action
of male hormones.
Banned in the developed world,
and the UN Environment Programme is trying to push through
a worldwide ban on the hazardous chemical, but malaria specialists
have campaigned against this, as DDT is used to kill the
mosquitoes that carry the disease.
Organophosphates: Those
used in sheep dip have been linked to excessive tiredness,
headaches, limb pains, disturbed sleep, poor concentration,
mood changes, and suicidal thoughts.